Foremost among these-why would Homer take up with Emily if he were not interested in her romantically?
Did Emily provide a convenient cover for his unspeakable predilections, or was she a confidante, a fellow "queer" to whom Homer was drawn instinctively?
Given the narrative framework of the story, we can only imagine-we are not privy to-the loneliness and longing that Emily must have felt to have killed a man and slept beside his decaying corpse; yet we must undertake perhaps an equivalent imaginative flight to comprehend the confusion and frustration endured by Homer Barron, a gay man in an age when homosexuality was virtually tantamount to necrophilia.
Given the unrelieved constraints of his predicament, accentuated by the small-town Southern setting, Homer understandably might have sought out a confessor, a sympathetic ear to whom he could divulge his guilty secret.
As the ghastly conclusion of the story makes clear, however, our narrator and the townspeople he represents had only and always seen Emily from the outside-as the fact that they penetrate the inside of her house only after her death emphasizes.
There are depths to Emily Grierson that the superficial gaze of the narrator could not reach.
Furthermore, the presumptive language of the narrator (e.g., "what else could") underscores his own unquestioning inferences, while at the same time teasing skeptical readers to consider, indeed, what else could have been going on.
We need to be more inquisitive, more penetrating, than our workaday narrator.
These same students might be heartened to learn that an obstinate allegiance to their own particular reading of the text, any text, is validated by the most voguish literary theory. If this is the case, then meaning is not something one discovers or extracts but, rather, something one confers or creates.
According to the new paradigm that obtains in the classroom-at least among the avant-garde--teachers should no longer assume the role of hierophant, the initiated priest practiced in the freemasonry of literary hermeneutics, while students, benighted acolytes, gape and scribble down our oracular pronouncements. This model supplants the old aristocratic ideal, where a powerful, privileged reader-the teacher-dispenses authorized readings, ex cathedra, to mute vassals.
Comments Rose Emily Essay Questions
A Rose for Emily - Southeast Missouri State University
Oct 2, 2018. Yet another question, or mystery, is why did Homer Barron, a rowdy. As Fish proclaims in his famous essay "Is There A Text In This Class. not only raises a new set of questions but transforms "A Rose for Emily," or at least.…
A Rose For Emily Essays Examples, Topics, Titles, & Outlines
View and download a rose for emily essays examples. to do all that he wants to do, such as "murder and create" 28, and "drop a question on your plate" 30.…
A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner sample essay free Example of.
This sample review essay paper is a book Analysis of A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner. How is the question of morality brought up within the story?…
A Rose for Emily Essay Essay -
Nov 6, 2005. Essays from BookRags provide great ideas for A Rose for Emily essays. We can also question the narrator's motive in why he felt a need to.…
A Rose for Emily Essay Bartleby
Free Essays from Bartleby Literary Analysis for “A Rose for Emily”. death, which brings the reader to question why this story has such a depressing tone upon.…
William Faulkner A Rose for Emily - Coe College
Of William Faulkner's story "A Rose for Emily," two general questions seem to. As was stated in the introduction to this essay, this question has absorbed.…
The Symbol of the Rose in William Faulkner's A Rose for Emily.
Category William Faulkner A Rose for Emily; Title The Symbol of the Rose. also prompts consideration into theories of motive surrounding the murder of Homer Barron. Symbolism and Theme in William Faulkner's A Rose for Emily Essay.…
Free a rose for emily Essays and Papers -
Free a rose for emily papers, essays, and research papers. a means to enhance the reader's visual perceptions but also prompts consideration into theories of.…
A Rose for Emily Essay Customs and Values - EssayShark
May 14, 2013. A Rose for Emily is a short story by William Faulkner which reflects the spirit of the time when it was written. The temporal and spatial setting of.…